Saturday, December 17, 2011

Fr. Nathan Monk in the news defending the homeless again

For an earlier post on Fr. Nathan Monk see here. His congregation is currently petitioning to be accepted into the Antiochian Church as a Western Rite parish.



(Pensacola Digest) - So, a priest walks into a city council meeting — stop me if you’ve heard this one — and is nearly hauled away by the police for speaking calmly to his elected officials.

Hilarious, right?

Father Nathan Monk wasn’t laughing at last night’s City Council meeting. During the Boyd Forum, an open comment period named in honor of the late civic activist LeRoy Boyd, Father Monk chided the council members — and Council President Sam Hall in particular — for their actions at Monday’s Committee of the Whole meeting. At that meeting, several citizens had spoken in opposition to the proposed anti-homeless ordinances, and in doing so made unflattering comparisons to historical figures (one person mentioned Heinrich Himmler’s “Final Solution“) and questioned the Christian charity of any council member who would support the ordinances. Council members DeWeese and Johnson took offense at the accusations, and Hall had asked Police Chief Chip Simmons to remove several speakers he deemed “out of order.”

At last night’s meeting, Monk told the council they had no right to dictate the content of their speech, and suggested that they instead examine any actions by the city that would prompt such comparisons.

“As Americans, we have the right to redress our government without fear of being arrested,” he said. “Whether or not they’re connecting dots from Hitler to George Wallace to Barney … you should be asking, ‘well what are we doing that’s allowing people to connect those dots?’ It was a sick and gross abuse of power.”

Council President Hall interrupted Monk at that point. “Your time is up, sit down,” he said.

“No, I have a minute and 12 seconds left,” Monk said, looking at the timer at the speaker’s lectern.

“I’m ruling you out of order,” Hall said.

When Monk refused to leave, noting that he had not violated any rules of conduct, Hall asked Police Chief Simmons and two other uniformed police officers in attendance to remove him. He refused to budge until his allotted time was up, after which he was escorted from council chambers by the officers.

During the standoff, council members Sherri Myers and John Jerralds stood up and left their seats in protest.

“I am leaving this chamber as you are in violation of the people’s First Amendment right,” Myers said. “I will be outside if you want to want to address your grievances to your government.”

Returning to her seat later in the meeting, she strongly criticized the “chilling effect” such censorship can have on the public right to speech...
Complete article here.

5 comments:

  1. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C_RsVkwxfGk

    ReplyDelete
  2. Interesting. Don't really understand the issues down there. Are they trying to forbid all food distribution by organizations or just some or is it about locations and permits? It would seem to me this needs to be clarified before people go off half cocked.
    I know of the existence of the mission, it and 2 or 3 others are listed as provisional at this time on the Western Rite Directory page. They have been listed there going on 2 years now. Not sure what the problem is but I'm sure this activity may be the cause.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's a very clear issue. Here's the info on the Large Group Feeding Ordinance:

    http://lawoftheland.wordpress.com/2010/08/06/11th-circuit-court-of-appeals-finds-large-group-feeding-ordinance-does-violate-first-amendment/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Josephus- Just a note- the blog you linked to in the comments section here refers to a law in Orlando (which is just one of many Orlando laws aimed at the homeless- others ban shaving or washing more than hands in a public restroom or doing laundry in Lake Eola). What Fr Nathan Monk is protesting in this article are similar laws they are trying pass in Pensacola, including a ban against standing on the side of the road with a sign.

    From Miami.

    ReplyDelete
  5. @Matthew - There could a number of reasons for their "provisional" status. I do not believe this would be one of them - since he is calmly acting within his Constitutional rights as well as within the Tradition of the Church. Remember that Christians brought Western Civilization public hospitals, orphanages, and a host of other social services. It is only in recent times that the socialist secular mentality has the state perform these functions.

    ReplyDelete