Is the male-only priesthood a discipline or essential to the nature of being a priest? Sr. Vassa (again unflinchingly taking up a contentious topic by climbing up the ladder to the highest platform and then jumping into the deep end head first) dives right in and says there is no reason beyond personal preference to not have female clergy. You know, when people ask me about women in priesthood, they say, 'Sister, why can't women be priests?' And I say, 'Women CAN be priests. We don't WANT them to be priests.' Because you see, God can do anything, and the Church, by divine authority, uh, can do anything, but, the Church doesn't want to - and that's a legitimate reason. What I don't like is when we TRY to pretend that there are other reasons for this, because it's legitimate not to want something, and there are reasons not to want this - right? - but, we shouldn't pretent that there's some... reason, that, for example, the maleness...
A Greek hierarch for the Ukrainian national Church. Very Catholic of the EP.
ReplyDeleteIt's as if anti-phyletism is really about maintaining Hellenism.
If the archimandrite in question "served many years in the Ecumenical Patriarchate and the Church of Greece", then it makes perfect sense that his bishop would release him back to the EP. Whether the Metropolitan followed the CoG's rules for such releases is a different question, but one could argue that releasing a vociferously pro-EP line regarding Ukraine from within a more skeptical CoG was the best thing to do anyway - especially if such release could be done with a deniable wink and nod by the Synod to this Metropolitan.
ReplyDeletePhyletism is such a Rorschach test for Orthodox. Some see it meaning all ethnic groupings should be eliminated under a single bishop (e.g., the Russians under the EP in France), others see it meaning something more akin to the situation of the EP and the OCA in the U.S. (and for the Greeks in Ukraine, now) which have ethnic dioceses overlapping geographical dioceses.
Your clarification helps.
DeleteOur Church, Old World style, names their country FIRST and then ”Orthodoxy” second. And then tell me to guard against phyletism!
Strange to me.
Every Orthodox diocese in the Americas is in violation of the 1872 Council. But nobody has figured out what Orthodox ecclesiology is post-Empire, so nobody knows what to do.
ReplyDelete