Tuesday, May 10, 2022

NPR ham-handedly attempts to grasp Orthodoxy

This article starts with an idea. It takes in every fact or opinion or person who shares that idea, and tries to create a connect-the-dots image of a shirtless Putin riding a horse. It also seeks to overlay every progressive position onto the page to show how fundamentalist Orthodoxy is taking over the Church. Does that sound familiar? It does. As will the names of those who concur with this view in the article. 

Let me be clear. Racism is silly. Nationalism over citizenship in heaven is misguided. The Church is a body built on love and a belief that this love is more powerful than any hate. Part of the beauty of Orthodoxy is that the host of saints is peopled with holy individuals from all over the world. All races, all nations, all united in love for God.

At the same time some people are drawn to the light of Orthodoxy and bring their heterodox opinions with them. In an attempt to join their desire for belonging with their desire to gain recognition for these preexisting beliefs, sometimes they find that the two pieces are incompatible. They find that those beliefs cannot be sanctified or even tolerated. As such, either the person throws off his former delusion or he moves on. Or, in the case of the person described below, he is excommunicated almost immediately.

You can't love God and hate your fellow man. You can't fly a flag any higher in the sky than the Divine One hung the stars in the sky. 

The below article attempts to connect ROCOR with hate, but it does this so poorly that the argument comes out weaker than had it not been posted at all. Worse, it pits cradle Orthodox against converts and jurisdiction against jurisdiction. People who feel that Orthodoxy and hate have no common cause in this country will feel maligned. People who feel that something about Orthodoxy gives succor to hate will become even more entrenched in that misapprehension. The needle didn't move here. If anything mutual mistrust of the "other" did. Somehow, I think this is not what the author intended.

(NPR) - When Sarah Riccardi-Swartz moved from New York City to a small Appalachian town in West Virginia in the fall of 2017, she was searching for an answer to a puzzling question. Why had a group of conservative American Christians converted to Russian Orthodoxy?

"It's typically an immigrant faith, so I was really interested in that experience and why it spoke to converts," said Riccardi-Swartz, a postdoctoral fellow in the Recovering Truth project at Arizona State University. She happened to miss the entire history of Orthodoxy's tremendous growth in the South (of which much information is available online) and somehow turn it into a racial isolationist movement with ties to, you guessed it... Russia Russia Russia.

Riccardi-Swartz's study focused on a community of mostly former evangelical Christians and Catholics who had joined the Russian Orthodox Church Outside of Russia (ROCOR). The West Virginia location, in addition to having a church parish, was also home to the largest English-speaking Russian Orthodox monastery in the world.

Over a year of doing research, Riccardi-Swartz learned that many of these converts had grown disillusioned with social and demographic change in the United States. In ROCOR, they felt they had found a church that has remained the same, regardless of place, time and politics. But Riccardi-Swartz also found strong strains of nativism, white nationalism and pro-authoritarianism, evidenced by strong admiration for Russian President Vladimir Putin. Have you ever visited a community and said "This parish is certainly representative of the three thousand Orthodox churches in the US?" Neither have I. A sample size of 0.0003 is quite a broad brush with which to paint a million people.

Putin as "king-like figure"

"For many of them, Putin becomes this sort of king-like figure in their narratives," she said. "They see themselves as oppressed by democracy because democracy is really diversity. And they look to Putin because democracy isn't really, as we see right now, an option [in Russia]." West Virginia being a bastion of diversity and integration. I'm sure the 94% Caucasian demographic feels besieged upon. Is it diversity or the almost seasonal innovationist thinking on every topic under the sun pushed for in the name of DEI that grates? Having been to WV numerous times I can well see how the social topics getting attention in the news bear little resemblance to the lives West Virginians are experiencing. Poverty, lack of medical care, alcoholism, the death of their forms of employment  etc. loom much larger for them than [insert pet topic].

She recently published a book based on her research that's titled Between Heaven and Russia: Religious Conversion and Political Apostasy in Appalachia.

The case study that Riccardi-Swartz provides adds detail and color to a trend that a handful of historians and journalists have documented for nearly a decade. In publications mostly targeted toward an Orthodox Christian audience, they have raised the alarm about a growing nativist element within the church. Despite Orthodoxy's relatively small imprint in the U.S., they warn that, unchecked, these adherents could fundamentally alter the faith tradition in the United States. They also warn that these individuals are evangelizing hate in the name of Orthodoxy in ways that could attract more who share those views.

"It's an immigrant faith. It's now being sort of colonized by these converts in many respects," said Riccardi-Swartz. "They're vocal in their parishes. They're vocal online. They're very digitally savvy and very connected to other far-right actors in the United States and across the globe. And that's really changing the faith." Beware the use of "colonized" in modern parlance. It's a byword for cabal-level scheming and nefarious intent. Orthodoxy might well be an immigrant faith in some places, but in every parish I have ever served, immigrants have made up a minority of the congregation. Orthodoxy is citizenship in Heaven, not national flags and favored foodstuffs or spirits. Those immigrants who do show up for Pascha or Nativity with a cornucopia of tasty items and ethnic CDs for the fellowship hall stereo system do so out of sentimental affinity more than from religious devotion. 

Orthodoxy's changing footprint in America

Despite centuries of presence in North America, starting in what we now know as Alaska, the Orthodox church in the U.S. is still relatively small. Alexei Krindatch, a sociologist of religion who focuses on Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox churches in the U.S., estimates that active adherents make up about 0.4% of the population. Within that, nearly two dozen branches are divided between what's known as Eastern Orthodoxy and Oriental Orthodoxy. They include Greek, Coptic, Ethiopian, Armenian and more.

Eastern Orthodox churches, which include ROCOR, flourished in the U.S. starting at the turn of the 20th century, when migrants flocked to major industrial hubs like New York, Chicago, Detroit and Cleveland for jobs. Over time, these churches concentrated in the Northeast and West Coast. But more recently, the size and location of Eastern Orthodox churches in the U.S. has changed. According to Krindatch, who conducts censuses of Orthodoxy in the U.S., parishes declined in size between 2010 and 2020.

"This is in line with American mainline religion, [where] everyone is shrinking in size except nondenominational churches," Krindatch said. But ROCOR, which Krindatch estimated in 2020 to have roughly 24,000 adherents, experienced a striking shift. While the number of ROCOR adherents declined by 14%, Krindatch found that the number of parishes grew by 15%. Well, this is poor statistical analysis. The average size of a ROCOR parish is a tiny fraction of the size of your standard GOA parish. If you build one Greek parish you would see a comparable ROCOR 10-20 parishes to be built for the same population. Hardly apples to apples. More like palm branches to pussy willows.

"So what it means [is], we have more parishes, but which are smaller in size. And if you look at the geography, those parishes were planted not in traditional lands of Orthodoxy," said Krindatch. The growth occurred in less populated areas of the Upper Midwest and Southern states, places with fewer direct links to Russia.

"So for me, those are a bunch of new ROCOR communities which are founded by convert clergy or by convert members," Krindatch said. The horror.

Aram Sarkisian, a postdoctoral teaching fellow at Northwestern University's Department of History, said this new growth from converts has helped some branches of Orthodoxy offset a decline in multigenerational families in the church. Sarkisian said these converts often find their way to Orthodoxy because they seek a haven for what they consider to be the most important cultural issues of the day.

"They're drawn to what they believe to be conservative views on things like LGBTQ rights, gender equality. Abortion is a really big issue for these folks, the culture wars issues, really," Sarkisian said. "And so they leave other faith traditions that they don't believe to be as stringent about those issues anymore." Not sure how to interpret "what they believe to be conservative views on things like LGBTQ rights." Is that a debatable point? Also, it's not a matter of stringency. It's an issue of large protestant bodies changing their opinions drastically in recent years. These people are not jumping ship. The ship is now a hovercraft that next week could be a dirigible. 

Sarkisian said he began to see white nationalist and nativist views surface within Orthodox spaces online just around the time that these shifts began taking place.

"I first started noticing this around 2010, 2011 on Orthodox blogs, where I started to see language and rhetoric that was subtly racist and was subtly engaging in what we would now know as the alt-right," Sarkisian said. "They bring it with them into the church because they see Orthodoxy as amenable to these goals, to these viewpoints."

Orthodoxy and the Unite the Right rally

Perhaps the most well known among Orthodox converts who worked within alt-right circles was Matthew Heimbach. He had established the Traditionalist Worker Party, which helped organize a deadly gathering of neo-Nazis and white nationalists at the Unite the Right rally in Charlottesville, Va., in 2017. But years before that, Heimbach's activities had already created waves within some Orthodox circles. Yes, those waves were "who the heck is this guy? He's not even Orthodox." In much the same way a researcher claiming to see national trends from a single Appalachian parish baffles the mind.

In 2014, he was excommunicated from the Antiochian Orthodox Christian Archdiocese of North America shortly after he had been accepted into it. During his brief time there, Heimbach's activities with other Orthodox converts on a college campus in Indiana drew scrutiny. In explaining the decision to cut Heimbach off from the church, the priest who had brought him into the church explained, "I did not understand at that time that he held nationalistic, segregationist views." Heimbach went on to join another branch of Orthodoxy. So, you're saying the single individual to which you attach a name to hate was immediately removed from the Church as soon as his heinous ideology was uncovered. Short of auto-da-fé, I'm not sure how the Church could have acted with more public decisiveness.

"And then after that all happened, basically, the bishops said, 'OK, it's all done. There is nothing to talk about anymore and nothing here to see,' " said Inga Leonova, the founder and editor of The Wheel, a journal on Orthodoxy and culture. The Wheel, of course. Heaven forbid you interview someone with a divergent opinion instead of someone who already wrote an article that parrots this one. 

Leonova, a member of the Orthodox Church in America, said she began following the trend of extremists joining Orthodoxy when she became aware of Heimbach's campus activities. When she writes about the topic, she said she receives threats from within the Orthodox community. Still, she has felt that silence on the issue has caused greater harm. In the wake of the Unite the Right rally, she said that bishops across Orthodox jurisdictions ignored calls to condemn the event and the rise of extremist ideologies in the church.

"I think that there must be a presence of a certain amount of aloofness and the lack of desire to engage with these topics because there is an Orthodox story that Orthodoxy and politics don't mix," she said.

But Leonova said this is fiction. An Orthodox Church in America priest from Ohio was briefly suspended after he was seen in a video wearing his cassock on Capitol grounds on Jan. 6, 2021, after he attended the Stop the Steal rally in Washington, D.C. And Leonova said other clergy members, themselves American converts to the faith, have signaled their political viewpoints on their social media pages and personal blogs. Right. Unlike in Russia, where you paradoxically think these men get their marching orders.

"There is a significant number of clergy whose social media profiles sport Confederate flags and support of the Southern cause," she said.

ROCOR's media-makers

Those who have followed the influx of extremists into American Orthodoxy agree that those individuals are fringe within the church and are mostly concentrated in newly founded ROCOR parishes. But they also warn that it would be foolish to ignore them. Of particular concern are the ways in which these individuals are networking with outside extremist groups and broadcasting their ideologies in the name of Orthodoxy. Influx? Is there a number here? Is there more than a single name you can attach this to? It's a convenient idea to use, but it lacks any real backing in this article. 

"I do actually think it's growing," said George Demacopoulos  a professor and the director of the Orthodox Christian Studies Center at Fordham University. "I don't think these people are necessarily changing the minds of people already in the church, but I do think they are bringing others culturally or politically like them into the church." I was mentally counting paragraphs until Fordham got a word in. It would be too much to call an actual Orthodox institution. I'm sure Demacopoulos visits West Virginia, or ROCOR parishes in general, regularly. Even if Jordanville demurred (see below), there are three more Russian tradition seminaries in the US.

In a viral social media clip pulled from a far-right internet talk show on the eve of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, former Republican U.S. Senate candidate Lauren Witzke of Delaware praised Russia as a "Christian nationalist nation." Witzke is studying to convert to ROCOR.

"I identify more with Russian — with Putin's Christian values — than I do with Joe Biden," Witzke said in the video. She declined to speak with NPR for this story.

Sarkisian said Witzke's view typifies those of far-right converts to ROCOR, who have been receptive to Kremlin propaganda portraying Putin as a pious defender of Orthodoxy and traditional values. He said Putin also represents to them an appealing style of authoritarian leadership that challenges pluralism and liberal democracy in the United States.

"They are anti-democratic by nature," Sarkisian said. "They are a part of these larger networks on the American far right, like Nicholas Fuentes and his America Firsters. They connect into these nodes that are challenging the very fabric of American democracy."

Witzke, a MAGA supporter who ran on an anti-immigration platform in 2020, has appeared on Orthodox podcasts, where she has identified herself as aligned with the white nationalist America First movement. She also, at one time, seemed to support QAnon conspiracy theories but has since renounced QAnon. The media ecosystem she has participated in, a network of American converts to ROCOR who produce podcasts and live video chats online, presents a highly politicized interpretation of Orthodoxy to the world and one that many believe offers a distorted view of the church.

"This is how people are finding Orthodoxy now. They're finding Orthodoxy through these YouTube shows. They're finding it through these podcasts. They're finding it through these blogs," said Sarkisian. "They're being radicalized by these folks on the internet, and that's really dangerous." Most of the people who come to my parish after going online listened to Pageau or De Young or old Hopko podcasts. Have yet to see anyone spouting racial superiority propaganda asking for chrism. Then again, the icon in the narthex is St. Moses the Ethiopian, so I might need to account for that in my anecdotal analysis.

The channels revolve around themes of antisemitism, contempt for women's and LGBTQ rights, xenophobia and support of white nationalists, including some who've been convicted of violent hate crimes. At times, clergy within ROCOR and other Orthodox branches have joined these online discussions, which may lend the appearance of sanctioning those views.

Some longtime ROCOR faithful have found these views bewildering, given the church's history. Lena Zezulin, whose parents were among the founding members of a parish in Long Island, N.Y., said that the community was always inclusive of non-Christian Russian immigrants living among it and proud of its immigrant roots.

"We had Muslims in the community," she recalled. "My summer camp had Buddhists in the community. So those people were kind of lovingly absorbed into the group because they all came over [to the U.S.] together."

She said that the congregation and clergy also welcomed her African American husband when they married roughly 40 years ago. But over time, their children started to encounter racism in the church. Zezulin said it tracked with the church's expansion to new regions of the U.S., where it was drawing new conservative converts. Zezulin said she believes tolerance for these views may explain why extremists with xenophobic and nativist views have been joining.

"It's outrageous, given that we came here as refugees and were accepted," she said. "I think it's racism based."

Russia's war in Ukraine

In general, those who have raised concern about racism and extremists' participation within the church say the issue has largely been left to parish priests to address — or not to address. NPR reached out to Holy Trinity Orthodox Seminary near Jordanville, N.Y., ROCOR's theological training institution, for comment on a number of questions, including how clergy are advised to handle the airing of antisemitic or nativist views by parishioners. Representatives declined to answer questions.

Most recently, Russia's war in Ukraine has prompted painful reflection among some faithful. The head of the Russian Orthodox Church, Patriarch Kirill of Moscow, gave religious cover to the war. He claimed that the invasion of Ukraine is necessary to protect Orthodox Ukrainians from Western influence — namely, gay pride parades. Zezulin left her longtime ROCOR community and has started attending an Orthodox Church in America parish because her priest would not condemn the invasion.

"You know, somebody just said we should stand and pray for both sides. Well, were the Brits supposed to pray for Hitler and Churchill at the same time?" she said. Of course they were. How could one miss that point?

If anything, said Sarkisian, the war has exposed just how Putin has used the Russian Orthodox Church to further his country's influence.

"It is definitely an arm of soft diplomacy, and ROCOR is a really important part of that," Sarkisian said. "Putin is really interested in the church for its purposes for amplifying a particular aspect of Russian history politically, religiously, culturally." One might be curious if they understood the history of ROCOR borne out of opposition to a totalitarian regime. Maybe read a bit on St. Tikhon or the Russian Church abroad or post-revolutionary Orthodoxy in general. That juxtaposition might have even made for a good article.


  1. Consider the source - NPR is a liberal mouthpiece of the left. First, they will never understand Christ as long as they espouse their teachings, and 2, they exist to sow division in all areas of life.

  2. Yet another example of why I am grateful working out our salvation doesn't require us to pay attention to all the idiocy and madness of the world falling apart around us. Much less wasting time arguing with every brainwashed idiot with a liberal arts degree.

    The world hated Christ, I don't know why so many are surprised that it hates Orthodoxy, but its far more concerning to me that so many Orthodox are doing everything they can to try and fit in with the world.

    1. "...its far more concerning to me that so many Orthodox are doing everything they can to try and fit in with the world...."

      Yep. While it's true that there is a real very hamfisted effort on the part of *some* (heavily represented by recent converts) to conflate their almost always "western" ideological (expressed in religious terms) baggage into Orthodox cosmology, theological anthropology, and ecclesiology, the far widespread and deeper problem is the easy integrationalism of so many secularized Orthodox.

  3. Too build upon what our host is saying, it is not a coincident that the author of this article quoted two leading sources/institutes/public voices for a modernism/Orthodox integrationalism within English speaking Orthodoxy: Inga Leonova and George Demacopoulos.

    George everyone is probably familiar with, and is a leading thinker and spokesperson for that NE "liberal" GOA brand of integrationalism that has so far been more shy about LBGTQwerty, though I understand his partner at Fordham, Aristotle, is going to come out with an explicitly pro LBGTQwerty philosophy soon.

    Inga is the current editor of "The Wheel" (the article states she is a founder - I did not know that) and personally identifies as LBGTQwerty and openly pushes a reform agenda (i.e. for this theological anthropology to be "integrated" within the Tradition) for it within the Church.

    If only the author had quoted Met. Kallistos (Timothy) Ware she would have nailed the trifecta.

  4. My wife told me a story about my mother-in-law working to teach kids how to write research papers: you don't start with the conclusion and look for supporting information, you do your research and see where that leads you. It seems that lesson has been lost on too many.

  5. Agree with most of your comments, however i agree with the point of YouTube. Most of the "Orthodox" represetitives on that medium that inquirers are mentioning are rather right wing and fringe. Particularly "debates". I wish respectable institutions like Ancient Faith and others invested in publishing more to YouTube.

    1. I am probably who this article is aimed at. I converted in a ROCOR church 3 years ago from a Baptist background. I actually was initially attracted by internet comments that didn't seem to be from either side of the culture wars, but from somewhere else, I was definitely looking for a church with a spine that wouldn't have a lesbian preacher within a few years. I probably do have some protestant beliefs I need to get rid of.
      While in some ways I am more right wing, the orthodox church has made me have some views which would be considered left wing. What it has done is melted my attachment to ideology. My politics are now the orthodox church.
      My frustration is what some orthodox label as fundamentalist but seem more in line with the church fathers than the modern views held by some orthodox. But I am still trying to aquire the mind of the church.

    2. Russell I think feeling like you don't fit in with either side politically means you are starting to acquire the mind of the church.